An Old Fashioned Family Murder
Dates: November 6-8 and 13-14, 2026
Times: Vary by performance
Tickets: $25.00 General Admission
"A murder. A mystery. A mother. It’s a dark and stormy night at the mansion of elderly Colonel Claythorne, and the pompous murder-mystery author Arthur Whittington is holding court with the Colonel’s family: his eldest daughter, Clarice, who is cold and glamorous; Clarice’s attractive fiancé, Jasper; Claythorne’s youngest daughter, Dotty, who is a big fan of Whittington’s; and Mrs. Shirley Peck, an unassuming but keenly observant visiting widow. When Whittington shares the news that the Colonel has modified his will to cut out one of his daughters – though which daughter won’t be revealed until the Colonel’s death – tempers flare. By the time Mrs. Peck’s son, (junior) Detective Paul Peck arrives at the house, there’s been a murder, and everyone is a suspect. With backstabbing, love and Mrs. Peck’s mother-knows-best advice complicating the investigation, it soon becomes clear that nothing – and no one – is what it seems."

Erin Caswell (Director)
Erin is a professional director and actor from Chicago and a St. Paul native. Her training includes a BA in Theatre Arts from Augsburg University in Minneapolis, intensive summer program with the Moscow Art Theatre in Cambridge MA, and TUTA Chicago. Since 2022 she has performed in or directed over 20 productions in the Brainerd Lakes Area at Stage North Theatre, Central Lakes College, GRA, and Actors Repertory Theatre. Favorites (besides this show!) include Gaslight/Angel Street, Misery, The Exonerated, God of Carnage, The Laramie Project, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever.

Mrs. Shirley Peck
A sweet, unassuming, and relentlessly underestimated visiting widow whose motherly instincts rival the official investigation.
Played by Tamara
McClintockSince moving to St.Cloud in 2012, Tamara has acted in or directed shows for GREAT Theatre, Great Northern Theatre, The Barn Theatre and Great River Arts. She was last seen as the bit muddled Myrtle in the 2025 Great River Arts production, You Can’t There From Here. In An Old-Fashioned Family Murder, Tamara loves playing Mrs. Peck. who is often overlooked by the men because she’s a woman in the 1940s, but she proves herself to be full of surprises!
Played by Collin Johnson
Clarice Claythorne
The Colonel’s cold, glamorous, and sharp-witted daughter.
Played by Abigail Arnold
Abigail participated in drama in high school, and after more than a decade long break, rediscovered her love of the stage here at Great River Arts. She has acted in several comedy plays at GRA, including Nunsense, The Fox on the Fairway, and You Can’t Get There From Here. She is having fun in her role as Clarice, and hopes that she and the rest of the cast can keep the audience guessing!
Dotty Claythorne
The Colonel’s Victorian-widow-dressed daughter who is a massive fan of mystery novels.
Played by Rebecca Simpson
Rebecca is originally from Madison South Dakota but has called Saint Cloud home now for over 20 years. She has been a ticket agent at Paramount Center for the Arts for 22 years and loves the theatre environment in any capacity. Her past performances include Great Theatre's 9-5 and CMNT Little shop of Horrors. Besides theatre Rebecca loves to solo travel throughout Europe and the USA. She is excited to be back in Little Falls to bring this comedy to life.

A pompous, world-renowned murder-mystery author with an affected accent who holds court over the family.
Played by Matthew M Toumi
Matthew M Toumi is an actor who has been involved in over 70 productions. He has a BA in Theatre and Film Studies from SCSU. He lives in Sauk Rapids and enjoys karaoke, watching movies, spending time with friends and family, and is a self confessed reality tv junkie. Some of the memorable shows he’s been involved with are RUMORS, MAMMA MIA, ELF, EXTREMITIES, TEN LITTLE INDIANS, YOU’RE A GOOD MAN, CHARLIE BROWN, and SCHOOL OF ROCK. He is a cashier and does bookwork at Circle K. 
Jasper Jamison
Clarice’s handsome but dim-witted fiancé.
Played by Nate Lundstrum
Nate Lundstrum lives and works in St. Cloud. This is his first time performing in Little Falls. He is excited to be in a play because the last one he did was "Flaming Idiots" in 2017. Nate has been involved in several musicals in the St. Cloud area, including Little Shop of Horrors, Beauty and The Beast and Green Day The Musical. In his free time he enjoys traveling, and spending time with his friends and family. He hopes the story keeps you guessing and laughing until the very end
OPEN MIC NIGHT
Join us on the GRA stage for our monthly Open Mic Nights! The area’s longest-running open mic invites you to bring your talent, whether it’s musical, literary, or otherwise. All ages are welcome, & all ages are regulars here at this supportive & enthusiastic session. Bring your voice or instrument ready to plug in and share!

Be sure to check regularly for upcoming events and live performances or follow us on our Facebook page, Great River Arts, for real time updates.
Thank you to Five Wings Arts Council, Minnesota State Arts Board, and the Clean Land Water Land and Legacy Amendment for their support.
"These activities are made possible, in part, by the voters of Minnesota, through a general operating grant from the Minnesota State Arts Board, thanks to a legislative appropriation from the arts and cultural heritage fund."
"These activities are made possible by the voters of Minnesota through a grant from the Five Wings Arts Council, thanks to a legislative appropriation from the Arts and Cultural Heritage Fund."
![]() |
|
